they are goodMy old workbooks completely fell apart, quick, messing my foot up pretty bad! I ordered these. Couldn't wait. Well, my messed up foot blew up like a freaking balloon. I got these boots and can only wear the right one. My messed up left foot is in a heavy duty slipper. I've been limping on this boot for 3 days now and let me tell you! This right boot is awesome! 5 stars...lol Edit: I'm back to normal now and I really like these boots.I may have ordered a half size too large but in the beginning these chafed just above the ankle and I thought they would just wear in.Didn’t happen yet, but I don’t wear these regularly. Even so, these seem like a very stiff boot to me and seemed to lack decent side support, I can’t seem to tie them tight enough around the top to get a comfortable fir.And not because they wore out prematurely, I bought one set 5 years ago. Another 2 years ago and 2 pairs this month so I can alternate them from one day to the next to let them breathe. They're super comfortable, have the composite toe guard and don't slip in oil. I work in a diesel truck shopBought these in July 2010. It was the worst pair of work boots I’ve ever own.Ive worn these while working in; warehouse, attic crawl space, working in the yard, construction site, you get the idea. I’ve put these babies through a lot. The stitch is holding quite well. I’m still wearing them as I’m finally looking for a replacement. Look no further I keep telling myself.The boots are very comfortable and works as expected. All I had to do was purchase special arch support in soles. Other than that, these are the best boots.Does a really good job keeping water out. I’ve worked in construction sites and since I haven’t truly experience a nail puncture perhaps it’s because it just prevented it without my awareness, these babies protected me for years.Buy them, don’t wait.As for maintenance, I’ve hosed it down and I always take the in soles out to air dry the interior. Never had any issues.What these boots been through: I was in the construction remodeling business, done a lot of personal DIY projects, crawled in the attic many times, worked in the warehouse, running various network and electrical cables, tons of yard renovation projects, a full house renovation down to the studs, plumbing, you get the idea...Gosh, I was really hoping these would last forever. What is forever?a well made boot with high quality materials. too narrow even in wide size for me. about average weight for this style boot. I did find my heal lifted out easy. ended up returning them. Ive tried a few different styles in the wolverines, always in wide and they all seem narrow to me. great boots if you dont have a wide foot.More comfortable than description. I read some reviews, and there was some that said they was a little small. ( After highschool, I worked in a shoe store, and realized most people, including myself, didnt know how to get a good fitting shoe, especially when it comes to kids shoe. They would say it was too tight, so would go a size up. However, what they really needed was a wider shoe.) With that being said, I got a 9W. They are a slight bit longer than expected, but not too much. And, I think the 8.5W would be a little to short. I would like to try these in a regular store to find out for sure. They almost fit like a 9.5M, and are actually just as long, but my foot doesnt slide around in these like my last pair, which was 9.5M. So be familiar w your foot when deciding on the size. Dont get the wrong idea. They are extremely comfortable. Lightweight. The insole is a lot more comfortable than the last pair of wolverine boots I bought ( Overman NT 6 in-$203 final price, and I had to buy new insoles after first use due to discomfort.) The insoles are great. As a matter of fact, when I get the extra cash, Im buying another pair just to have for when these are done, which im figuring will be at least a year. Once again great boot. FYI: if this or any boot/shoe causes discomfort on top of foot, try lacing them differently. I discovered this reading a Running magizine. Skip the 2nd or third to last set of holes . Trial and error.... once again, i would highly recommend this boot.So, it's only day one but after 12 hours on my feet these boots are everything I'd hoped for so I thought I'd drop an early review. They were comfortable right out of the box and they look pretty good as well. The laces seem sturdy and I like the way they lace up (some other brands cheap out on this area). I will be sure to update this review in a couple months - I spent many hours researching boots (online and in store) after not being so happy with the last couple pairs I've owned, so I know the importance of good reviews.Time will tell on the durability, seems that most boots that are this comfortable straight away seem to lack the longevity of some other boots. I work at a power plant, standing 12 hour shifts so comfort and durability are the two most important things. I don't know whether the material will hold up to the oils and greases that inevitably find their way onto my boots - we will see. I also look for a boot that is water proof, but provides some breath-ability as well - these seem to hit the mark there, my feet were not sweaty at all.Amazon's price and service made this the place to buy them - even though my company reimburses my cost, I felt that saving the few dollars on Amazon is the way to go. Two day shipping and free returns... just can't beat it!